Posts Categorized: Constitutional

Excessive Fines Clause in California: Constitutional Limits on Government Penalties

Land use attorneys in Sacramento, CA and Los Angeles, CA

Consider a property owner who receives a notice from a local agency imposing daily penalties for an unpermitted structure. The penalties continue to accumulate, and the total eventually approaches the value of the property. Can the government legally impose penalties that high? The Excessive Fines Clause of the Eighth Amendment addresses this concern. However, a… Read more »

Coercion by Government in California: Constitutional Limits on Agency Power

Land use attorneys in Sacramento, CA and Los Angeles, CA

A government agency offers you a permit, but only if you agree to give up land, waive a right, or pay a fee that appears unrelated to the permit’s purpose. A regulator conditions approval of a development project on the owner’s agreement to provide public access across private property. A city demands a dedication of… Read more »

Ripeness in California Takings Claims: When Is a Claim Ready to Sue?

Land use attorneys in Sacramento, CA and Los Angeles, CA

A property owner may believe the government has gone too far. A zoning restriction, permit denial, or development condition may appear to eliminate the property’s value or prevent any reasonable use. The owner may want to bring a constitutional takings claim immediately. But a potential taking is only part of the analysis. In a regulatory… Read more »

First English v. Los Angeles County: Temporary Regulatory Takings

Land use attorneys in Sacramento, CA and Los Angeles, CA

Government regulations can restrict what a property owner may build, develop, or do on private land. Most restrictions do not rise to the level of a constitutional taking. Some, however, may go so far that they interfere with property rights to an extent that requires compensation. That raises an important question when the restriction is… Read more »

California Constitution vs. U.S. Constitution: Property Owner Rights

Land use attorneys in Sacramento, CA and Los Angeles, CA

Many California property owners think of constitutional rights in broad terms. These protections can involve property rights, due process, and limits on government power. However, two constitutional frameworks may apply to these issues: the United States Constitution and the California Constitution. In many situations, the California Constitution provides broader protections. That distinction is not merely… Read more »

The 10th Amendment in California: Limits on Government Power

Land use attorneys in Sacramento, CA and Los Angeles, CA

Government authority in the United States is not unlimited. The federal government operates within the powers the Constitution grants to it. State governments exercise broad authority, but they operate within both the federal Constitution and their own state constitutions. Local governments in California exercise only the authority state law grants to them. That structure of… Read more »

Section 1983 Claims in California: Challenging Government Actions

Land use attorneys in Sacramento, CA and Los Angeles, CA

When a government official violates your constitutional rights, the harm is not necessarily addressed through the criminal system. Federal civil rights law provides a separate mechanism: a civil lawsuit filed directly against the government actor responsible. That mechanism is codified at 42 U.S.C. § 1983. Section 1983 is not a law that creates constitutional rights…. Read more »

Precondemnation Entry on Private Property in California

Land use attorneys in Sacramento, CA and Los Angeles, CA

Government agencies don’t always wait for condemnation proceedings before entering private land. Sometimes, they need access before they decide whether to take the property at all. This process is called precondemnation entry, and it raises serious constitutional questions for California property owners. Property owners have specific rights during this process that deserve close attention. The… Read more »

Appeals Lawyers Analyze Shelby County v. Holder and the Constitutionality of Section 4 of the Voting Rights Act

Two weeks ago several US congressmen put forward a bill to implement a modified version of Section 4 of the Voting Rights Act. The bill is an explicit response to last year’s supreme court ruling in Shelby County v. Holder striking down Section 4 of the Voting Rights Act as unconstitutional. Given the controversy and… Read more »

U.S. Supreme Court to Decide Whether Private Home Assistants Can be Compelled to Join a Union Against Their Will

Land use attorneys in Sacramento, CA and Los Angeles, CA

This term the US Supreme Court will have the opportunity to decide whether the state can force private home assistants to join a public employee union. Recently, the Court agreed to hear arguments from appeal lawyers in Harris v Quinn. That case challenges the constitutionality of an Illinois executive order that declared personal home assistants (i.e…. Read more »