SACRAMENTO | LOS ANGELES
Call our Offices: 877-770-7379

How Post-Trial Motions Extend the Time to Appeal in California

extend time to appeal californiaA party loses at trial and files a post-trial motion. Meanwhile, the deadline to appeal may continue running.

California Rules of Court, rule 8.108, governs when certain post-trial motions extend that deadline. Only specified filings qualify, and each must meet procedural requirements. Even then, the extended deadline usually falls on the earliest of several dates.

What Is California Rule 8.108?

The starting point is rule 8.104(a). A party must file a notice of appeal by the earliest of these dates:

  • 60 days after the clerk serves notice of entry of judgment.
  • 60 days after a party serves that notice with proof of service.
  • 180 days after entry of judgment.

Except as rule 8.66 provides, courts cannot extend these deadlines. Rule 8.104(b) requires dismissal of a late appeal.

Subdivision (a) of rule 8.108 clarifies that the rule only extends the appeal deadline. It never shortens it. A longer period under rule 8.104 still controls.

Every extension requires a valid filing. The advisory comment explains that “valid” means procedurally compliant, not successful on the merits. Each subdivision also identifies its own triggering event. The filing must meet the requirements for that specific motion.

The guide to filing an appeal in California explains how the appeal process begins.

Which Post-Trial Motions Can Extend the Appeal Deadline?

Subdivisions (b) through (e) cover four types of trial court filings.

Motion for New Trial

Subdivision (b) applies when a party serves and files a valid notice of intention to move for a new trial. The notice triggers the extension, not the later motion papers.

Under section 659, the party must file the notice with the clerk and serve the other parties. The notice must state the grounds. Supporting papers follow separately. A court order or stipulation cannot extend the notice deadlines.

If the court denies the motion

A denial extends the appeal deadline for all parties. The new deadline falls on the earliest of these dates:

  • 30 days after service of the order denying the motion or notice of entry.
  • 30 days after denial by operation of law.
  • 180 days after entry of judgment.

The clerk or a party may serve the order or notice. Denial by operation of law occurs when the court’s time to rule under section 660 expires. Subdivision (b)(1) applies only when the court denies the motion.

If the court issues a conditional order

Subdivision (b)(2) addresses a conditional order based on excessive or inadequate damages. The court orders a new trial unless a party accepts a reduced award (remittitur) or an increased award (additur).

If a party timely accepts the change, the appeal deadline runs until 30 days after service of that acceptance. If the party rejects the change or the acceptance period expires, the deadline to appeal the new trial order is extended. The deadline falls on the earlier of 30 days after rejection or 30 days after expiration.

Motion to Vacate a Judgment

Subdivision (c) applies to a valid notice of intention to move, or a valid motion, to vacate a judgment. The party must serve and file it within the rule 8.104 appeal period.

The extension applies to all parties. The new deadline falls on the earliest of these dates:

  • 30 days after service of the order denying the motion or notice of entry.
  • 90 days after the first notice of intention or motion is filed.
  • 180 days after entry of judgment.

The advisory comment explains that subdivision (c) covers statutory motions and motions based on a void judgment or extrinsic fraud. Two statutory provisions are particularly relevant.

  • Section 663. Section 663 allows a party to ask the same court to set aside a judgment and enter a different one. The grounds include an incorrect legal basis for the decision or a conflict with a special verdict. The notice of intention must comply with section 663a, which also sets limits on the court’s ruling period.
  • Section 473(b). Section 473(b) allows relief for mistake, inadvertence, surprise, or excusable neglect. A party must file within a reasonable time, no later than six months.

The six-month period can extend beyond the appeal deadline. However, rule 8.108(c) requires the party to file within the rule 8.104 appeal period. A later section 473(b) motion may not extend the deadline.

Why the motion must be valid

In Payne v. Rader (2008) 167 Cal.App.4th 1569, the trial court sustained a demurrer without leave to amend. The losing party then moved to vacate under section 663.

The court held that section 663 did not apply to that judgment. The motion was invalid and did not extend the appeal deadline. The court dismissed the appeal.

Rule 8.108 covers qualifying motions, not every postjudgment request for relief.

Motion for Judgment Notwithstanding the Verdict

A motion for judgment notwithstanding the verdict (JNOV) asks the court to rule for the moving party despite the jury’s verdict. Section 629 permits this motion when the court should have directed a verdict for that party. Section 659 governs its timing.

A valid JNOV motion that the court denies extends the appeal deadline for all parties. The new deadline falls on the earliest of these dates:

  • 30 days after service of the denial order or notice of entry.
  • 30 days after denial by operation of law.
  • 180 days after entry of judgment.

The extension covers the judgment. However, section 904.1(a)(4) also makes an order denying JNOV separately appealable.

Under subdivision (d)(2), rule 8.104 governs the deadline to appeal that order. Only the cross-appeal provision in subdivision (g)(2) can add time.

Motion for Reconsideration of an Appealable Order

Subdivision (e) applies only to a valid motion to reconsider an appealable order under Code of Civil Procedure section 1008(a).

Section 1008(a) requires the party to file within 10 days after service of notice of entry. The motion must rely on new or different facts, circumstances, or law.

The extension applies to all parties. The new deadline falls on the earliest of these dates:

  • 30 days after service of the order denying the motion or notice of entry.
  • 90 days after the first reconsideration motion is filed.
  • 180 days after entry of the appealable order.

This extension covers only the order under reconsideration. It does not extend the deadline to appeal a final judgment.

In Ramon v. Aerospace Corp. (1996) 50 Cal.App.4th 1233, a postjudgment reconsideration motion did not extend the time to appeal the judgment.

The advisory comment cites Ramon and explains that the rule applies only to a party’s motion. Courts have disagreed about whether an order denying reconsideration is itself appealable. The article Motion for Reconsideration vs. Appeal in California discusses that issue.

Cross-Appeals and Public Entity Actions

Subdivision (g)(1) gives other parties 20 days after the clerk serves notice of a timely first appeal. Those parties may then appeal the same judgment or order.

Subdivision (g)(2) also provides 20 days to appeal the original judgment or an order denying JNOV. This applies when the first appeal challenges an order granting a new trial or a JNOV judgment. It also covers an order granting a motion to vacate within 150 days after entry of judgment.

Subdivision (f) addresses certain requests by public entity defendants under Government Code sections 962, 984, and 985.

How Is the Extended Appeal Deadline Calculated?

Each subdivision sets out several possible deadlines. The earliest date controls. However, rule 8.108 cannot shorten the time allowed under rule 8.104. The applicable deadline is therefore the later of the two.

The table assumes each filing meets the applicable procedural requirements.

Qualifying filing Relevant triggering event Potential extension limit
New trial motion, (b)(1) Valid notice of intention served and filed. Denial by order or by operation of law. Earliest of 30 days after service, 30 days after operation-of-law denial, or 180 days after entry.
Conditional new trial order, (b)(2) Service of an acceptance or a rejection, or expiration of the acceptance period. Acceptance: 30 days after service. Rejection or expiration: the earlier of 30 days after the rejection or after expiration.
Motion to vacate, (c) Valid notice or motion filed within the rule 8.104 period. Denial order served. Earliest of 30 days after service, 90 days after the first filing, or 180 days after entry.
JNOV motion, (d)(1) Valid motion served and filed. Denial by order or by operation of law. Earliest of 30 days after service, 30 days after operation-of-law denial, or 180 days after entry.
Reconsideration of an appealable order, (e) Valid section 1008(a) motion. Denial order served. Earliest of 30 days after service, 90 days after the first motion, or 180 days after entry of the order.

Two Fictional Examples

Assume the court enters judgment on March 1, 2027. A party serves notice of entry on March 8, making May 7 the ordinary appeal deadline.

On March 16, the party serves and files a valid notice of intention to move to vacate under section 663. The denial order is served on April 13.

The relevant dates are:

– 30 days after service of the denial order: May 13
– 90 days after the motion was filed: June 14
– 180 days after entry of judgment: August 28

May 13 is the earliest of these dates. Because it falls after the May 7 ordinary deadline, the appeal deadline extends to May 13.

Now consider a different situation. A party files a valid section 473(b) motion on March 16. The denial order is served on May 25.

The relevant dates are:

– 30 days after service of the denial order: June 24
– 90 days after the motion was filed: June 14
– 180 days after entry of judgment: August 28

June 14 is the earliest date. It also falls after the May 7 ordinary deadline, so the appeal deadline extends to June 14.

These examples illustrate how the deadlines interact. The applicable dates depend on the motion, its filing, and service of the court’s order.

Do All Post-Trial Motions Extend the Time to Appeal?

No. Rule 8.108 covers specific filings. Other post-trial requests do not automatically extend the appeal deadline. Three situations illustrate the distinction:

  • A qualifying motion. The motion falls within a subdivision and meets its procedural and timing requirements. The corresponding extension applies.
  • A motion outside the rule. Rule 8.108 does not cover the filing. A motion for reconsideration after entry of judgment is one example. Ramon held that such a motion did not extend the appeal deadline. Informal requests and settlement discussions also do not qualify.
  • A defective filing. The motion falls within a listed category but fails a procedural requirement. The section 663 motion in Payne illustrates this situation.

A pending motion does not automatically pause the appeal deadline. If a party files a late notice of appeal, the reviewing court must dismiss the appeal under rule 8.104(b). Filing a post-trial motion alone does not preserve the right to appeal.

What Happens If the Trial Court Denies the Motion?

Denial starts the applicable countdown under rule 8.108. For subdivisions (b) through (e), the 30-day period generally runs from service of the denial order or notice of entry. Either the clerk or a party may serve the document.

The service date controls, not the date the judge signs the order. Rule 8.108(h) requires proof of service for a served order or notice. That proof establishes the relevant date.

Subdivisions (b) and (d) also address denial by operation of law. Subdivisions (c) and (e) do not. Their respective 90-day limits therefore remain important.

The denial does not create an unlimited new appeal period. Each subdivision sets specific deadlines, including a 180-day limit measured from entry of judgment or the relevant appealable order.

Why Should Parties Track Both the Motion and Appeal Deadlines?

  • Keep file-endorsed copies of every notice, motion, and order.
  • Confirm service dates and retain proofs of service for each ruling and notice of entry.
  • Check the docket for minute orders, written orders, and notices of entry.
  • Confirm that each motion qualifies under the correct subdivision.
  • Calculate both the ordinary and extended appeal deadlines. Do not assume a pending motion suspends every appellate deadline.

The appellate record comes from the trial court file, as explained in what goes into the appellate record. After filing, parties may also want to know how long a California civil appeal takes.

Match the Motion to the Rule

Rule 8.108 extends the time to appeal only for qualifying filings. Identifying the correct subdivision and calculating from the applicable event helps protect the right to appeal.

Kassouni Law represents private parties in appellate matters. If a post-trial motion may affect your appeal deadline, the firm can review the circumstances and discuss available legal options.

Call Kassouni Law at (877) 770-7379 or contact the firm to discuss your situation. Submitting a contact form does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does filing a motion for a new trial extend the time to appeal in California?

It can. Under rule 8.108(b), a valid notice of intention extends the time if the motion is denied. The deadline is the earliest of three dates. An invalid or late notice may extend nothing.

Does a motion to vacate a judgment extend the appeal deadline?

It can, under rule 8.108(c). The party must serve and file a valid notice of intention or motion within the rule 8.104 appeal period. A later filing may extend nothing.

Does a motion for reconsideration pause the time to appeal?

Not as a pause. Rule 8.108(e) can extend the time to appeal a specific appealable order after a valid section 1008(a) motion. It does not extend the time to appeal a final judgment.

What happens if the court denies a post-trial motion?

Denial usually starts a short countdown, not a fresh appeal period. The deadline is the earliest of the listed dates. Proof of service shows when the countdown began.

Can multiple post-trial motions extend the appeal deadline more than once?

The rule does not provide for stacking. Subdivisions (c) and (e) measure 90 days from the first filing. Subdivisions (b)(1), (c), (d), and (e) also set 180-day limits. A second motion should not be assumed to add time.

The information provided here is for general informational purposes only and is not legal advice. Post-trial deadlines and available relief depend on the type of case, the dates involved, and the law in effect. Consult a qualified attorney about your circumstances.

Tags: , , , , ,